manhattan-insitute/Three
years after the end of the 2007–09 recession, which officially began
in December 2007 and ended in June 2009, 47 million people each month
are using the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP). At the
beginning of the recession, fewer than one in 10 Americans received
SNAP benefits. Nearly 15 percent of Americans now use SNAP
benefits, formerly called food stamps, a program administered by the
United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). This translates to more
than one in 7 Americans currently using SNAP benefits, a record
non-emergency high.[
2]
There is much concern surrounding this unprecedented increase in
America's SNAP program, which began in 2008. Food stamp participation
has always increased during a recession and in the initial stages of a
recovery. The purpose of this report is to determine
whether the recent increase in SNAP participation is comparable to
increases during other recent recessions. Our results demonstrate that
levels seen since the end of this recession are far higher than in
prior recoveries (see Figure 1). While the 36 month periods
following the recessions of the early 1980s saw decreases in food stamp
usage, the recessions of the early 1990s and in 2001 saw increases
between 1 and 2 percent over the same period, in comparison
with an increase of 3.5 percent following the recession ending in
2009. In addition to the difficult job market, this is because of
changes in the program that began in October 2008, including expansion
of benefits and elimination of the cap for child care expenses.
History of Eligibility
Inception and Expansion of the Food Stamp Program
Since its inception on a national scale in 1964 through the Food
Stamp Act of 1964, eligibility requirements have periodically been
expanded and tightened with each reauthorization bill. Large increases
in participation reflect not only population growth and
economic variation, but also responses to eligibility changes. For
instance, the program originally had a purchase requirement meaning
that recipients were required to purchase food stamps, "paying an
amount commensurate with their normal expenditures for food
and receiving an amount of food stamps representing an opportunity
more nearly to obtain a low-cost nutritionally adequate diet."[
3] This requirement was later eliminated.
In 1971, P.L. 91-671 "Amendments to the 1964 Food Stamp Act"
standardized national eligibility and work requirements. It also
expanded the Food Stamp Program to Guam, Puerto Rico, and the U.S.
Virgin Islands. In 1974, P.L. 93-347, Domestic Food
Assistance Program authorized USDA to pay 50 percent of states'
administrative costs. There were 10 million participants in 1971. This
grew to nearly 14 million in 1974.
Limitations in the Late 1970s and Early 1980s
The Food Stamp Act of 1977, which went into effect January 1, 1979,
set the net income threshold for food stamps eligibility at 100 percent
of the poverty line. For current eligibility thresholds, see Table 1.
The 1977 Act also eliminated categorical eligibility and
replaced a number of income deductions with a standard deduction. The
Act restricted student and alien eligibility, and penalized household
heads who voluntarily quit jobs. However, the resource
limit was also increased. The most significant structural change to the
program under this Act was the elimination of the purchase
requirement. Once the purchase requirement was eliminated in January
1979, there was a 1.5 million increase in food stamp
program participants. The Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1981
added a gross income limit of 130 percent of poverty (for households
with no elderly or disabled members).
Expansions in the Mid- to Late-1980s
In response to widespread domestic hunger problems, legislators
eased requirements for participation. The resources limit was increased
to $2,000, categorical eligibility was reinstituted, the homeless
became eligible, and the advanced earned income tax credits
were excluded from income calculations. Also, sales taxes on food
stamp purchases were eliminated, and applying medical deductions was
made easier.
Table 2 and Figures 2, 3, and 4 show the average income and benefit levels per participant in real terms from 1989 to 2010.
Limitations in the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunities Reconciliation Act of 1996
As can be seen in Figure 2, average income of program participants
increased between 1996 and the early 2000s, after having declined
slightly between 1989 and 1996. The 1996 welfare legislation eliminated
eligibility of legal immigrants, placed a three month
limit on Able-Bodied Adults Without Dependents (ABAWDs) working less
than 20 hours a week over 36 month period, reduced the maximum
allotment, froze the standard deduction and minimum benefit, and
revised provisions for disqualification.
Expansions and Changes in the Farm Bills of 2002 and 2008
In May 2002, the food stamp program was changed under the Farm
Security and Rural Investment Act which restored eligibility of legal
immigrants, indexed the standard deduction to inflation, incentivized
state administration outcomes with performance bonuses,
simplified eligibility processes for states by aligning them with other
means-tested programs, and cut employment and training funds.

The increase in participation in 2008 was caused by a combination of
widened benefit eligibility, the recession, and a concerted effort to
expand access to benefits. The 2008 Farm Bill changed the name of the
program from the Food Stamp Program to SNAP, in an effort
to reduce the social stigma associated with receiving benefits. As of
October 1, 2008, the minimum benefit and standard deduction for
households were increased. The cap for child care expenses was
also eliminated. There were also changes aimed at combating fraud,
including disqualification of people who sold benefits or food
obtained with SNAP benefits for cash, and the bill allowed the USDA more
flexibility in setting consequences including fines and
disqualification periods for retailers who engaged in food stamp
fraud.[
4]
Current Funding and Eligibility
The current income limits are listed in Table 1. In order to receive
SNAP benefits, most households must have both a gross income under 130
percent of the poverty level and a net income under 100 percent of the
poverty level. Households with an elderly or disabled
member need only have a net income under 100 percent of the poverty
line.
Furthermore, households in which all members receive public
assistance (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, formerly Aid to
Families with Dependent Children, and Supplemental Security Income) are
automatically eligible.
Additionally, households are permitted to have $2,000 ($3,250 for
households with a senior or disabled person) in "countable resources,"
which include banks accounts, vehicles, and some other household
assets.
Recipients are allowed to make deductions which determine the
difference between the household's gross and net incomes. Twenty
percent of earned income may also be deducted, as well as a standard
deduction of $147 for a household with one to three members,
or $155 for larger households. Households may deduct some expenses,
including child care (when necessary for work, training, or education),
child support, medical bills, and in some cases shelters and utilities
costs.[
5]
ABAWDs ages 18-50 are still generally limited to three months of
SNAP benefits within a three year period if they do not work or
participate in workfare or workforce training programs.[
6]
However, in some areas these requirements can be waived.
Employment and training grants are used to assist SNAP participants
with attaining, retaining, and training for work opportunities.
The Food Stamp Act of 1964 stipulated that the federal government
funds benefits (and bears responsibility for authorization of retailers
and wholesalers), and the states handle certification and issuance.
The costs of administering the program are shared between
the federal government and the states. For most activities the federal
government pays 50 percent. However, the federal government pays for
100 percent of employment and training grants, and nutrition
education programs, and 75 percent of the administration costs for
Indian reservations.
Analysis of Recovery Participation Data
The expansion of the program had a predictable effect: use of the
program rose. This can be seen from our analysis of 36 months of data
for the five most recent recession recoveries from 1980 to the present,
beginning in the month the recession ended. (June 2012
figures are the latest data available for SNAP participation.) We
examine the 1980 recession from January 1980 to July 1980; the 1981–82
recession from July 1981 to November 1982; the 1990–91 recession
from July 1990 to March 1991; the 2001 recession from March 2001
to November 2001; and the most recent 2007–09 recession, from December
2007 to June 2009.
Figure 1 shows that SNAP usage has been far higher both during the
2007–09 recession and thereafter than following prior recessions. In
June 2009, 11.4 percent of the population was on SNAP (compared to 9.3
percent when the recession began in December 2007).
Thirty-six months afterward, in June 2012, the percent of the
population on SNAP had increased by 3.5 percentage points, to 14.9
percent.
The 2001 recession saw an increase of 2.1 percentage points in the
36 months following the end of the recession, from 6.5 percent at the
end of the recession to 8.6 percent. The level of usage and the
increase were dramatically lower than the recession of
2007–09.
During the three-year period following the 1991 recession, the
percentage of people using food stamps rose by 1.6 percentage points,
from 9.2 percent to 10.8 percent.

In
contrast, the percentage of people who used food stamps declined
during the three-year period after the 1980s recessions, by just under
one percentage point after the 1981–82 recession, and by over half a
percentage point following the 1980 recession.
The length of the recession does not have a direct relationship to
the increase (or decrease) in food stamp usage during the recovery (see
Table 3). While the 18-month 2007–09 recession ending in June 2009
yielded a 3.5 percentage point increase in the share of the
population using SNAP benefits, the 16-month recession ending November
1982 saw a 0.9 percentage point decrease. Of course, there are many
factors at play, and one of the most important is likely how
prolonged employment effects were during recoveries from these
recessions.
States
June 2012 data show while nationwide participation was 15 percent,
state participation rates vary from 6 percent to 22 percent (with 23
percent of District of Columbia residents on food stamps.) The wide
variation in participation can be explained by two main
factors: differences in state economies and variation in the
eligibility rules adopted by individual states. Figure 5 presents the
unemployment rates as well as the share of the population receiving
SNAP benefits. Contrary to what might be expected, the
unemployment rate and food stamp participation rate do not appear to
have a strong relationship. This would suggest that the differences in
eligibility and other administrative standards play a large
role in varying participation rates. One consistent relationship is
that, with the exceptions of California and New Jersey, the percentage
of the population on food stamps always exceeded the state's
unemployment rate. California residents have a low
participation rate because in SNAP because SSI recipients receive a
state SSI supplement instead of SNAP benefits.[
7]

States have the ability to place some restrictions on SNAP use.
States have some control over the administration of deductions, which
can only amount to the difference between gross and net household
income. For example, states can choose whether or not to
exclude some or all of the value of the household's primary vehicle
when assessing income and countable resources. Thirty-nine states
exclude any vehicle value when assessing a household's resources, 11
states exclude the value of one or more vehicles, and three
states "exempt an amount higher than the SNAP's standard auto
exemption (currently set at $4,650) from fair market value to determine
countable resource value of a vehicle."[
8] States may also choose to allow exemptions for homeless shelter costs up to $143, and utility costs.[
9] A complete list of state options is listed in Table 4.
Fraud
According to the USDA's Office of Research Analysis, rates of fraud have been declining. In a March 2011 report entitled
The Extent of Trafficking in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program: 2006–2008,
the Department summarized trafficking data for several
summary periods. In 1993 the total amount of SNAP benefits reached $22
billion.[
10]
Of these, $811 million, or about 3.8 percent, were diverted by
trafficking. Six hundred and sixty million dollars, a rate
of 3.5 percent, were trafficked between 1996 and 1998. From 1999 to
2002, the average annual trafficking amount was $393 million, or 2.5
percent of the total benefits, and from 2002 to 2005, the rate
decreased to one percent with $241 million per year being misused.
In 2006–08, though the trafficking amount increased to $330 million
annually, the rate remained one percent.[
11]
Conclusion
The increase in food stamp usage following the most recent 2007–09
recession vis-à-vis the smaller increases in other recessions is
troubling. Designing and administering a social safety net is a
balancing act. While assisting and empowering those who are
truly in need, we must guard against creating perverse incentives to
depend on public assistance for long term sustenance.
It is important to acknowledge that unemployment rate has remained
above 8 percent for 43 months, since February 2009, which is longer
than in any other recession since 1980. However, Americans experienced
unemployment over 8 percent for 27 months from November
1981 to January 1984, but ultimately saw a decrease in food stamp usage
during the 36 months following that recession. The prolonged
unemployment effects of the 2007–09 recession are partly
responsible for the growth in current food stamp usage, but cannot
fully explain it. More likely, increased eligibility, income
deductions, and benefit levels have precipitated unprecedented growth in
the program.
The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program is to be applauded for
making strides in combating fraud, allowing state flexibility in
administration, and providing the neediest citizens with choices in how
to best fulfill their dietary needs. But the data beg the
question: Does 15 percent of our population truly qualify as the
neediest among us?
ENDNOTES
- The author is grateful to Claire Rogers of the Manhattan Institute,
Leah Loversky of Pomona College, and Chi Zhang of Swarthmore College
for research help with this Issue Brief. All errors are her own.
- Food stamp usage typically spikes during and after natural disasters.
- USDA, Food and Nutrition Services, Supplemental Nutrition
Assistance Program, A Short History of SNAP, April 16, 2012,
http://www.fns.usda.gov/snap/rules/Legislation/about.htm.
- USDA, Food and Nutrition Services, Supplemental Nutrition
Assistance Program, A Short History of SNAP, April 16, 2012,
http://www.fns.usda.gov/snap/rules/Legislation/about.htm.
- U.S. Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition Services,
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program Eligibility, April 11, 2012,
http://www.fns.usda.gov/snap/applicant_recipients/eligibility.htm.
- U.S. Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition Services,
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program Eligibility, April 11, 2012,
http://www.fns.usda.gov/snap/applicant_recipients/eligibility.htm.
- USDA, Food and Nutrition Services, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program Eligibility, April 11, 2012, http://www.fns.usda.gov/snap/applicant_recipients/eligibility.htm.
- USDA, Food and Nutrition Services, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program Eligibility, April 11, 2012, http://www.fns.usda.gov/snap/applicant_recipients/eligibility.htm.
- USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
Program, State Options Report, Ninth Edition, November 2010, http://www.fns.usda.gov/snap/rules/Memo/Support/State_Options/9-State_Options.pdf. This document includes state flexibilities in place as of November 2010, a more current version is due out this fall.
- USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program Participation and Costs (Data as of July 26, 2012), http://www.fns.usda.gov/pd/SNAPsummary.htm.
- USDA, Food and Nutrition Service, Office of Research and Analysis, The Extent of Trafficking in the Supplem